Toddler Talk: Helping Your Little One Cope With a New Baby

For a toddler, a new sibling isn't good news they're too young to appreciate. It means sharing the two people they depend on most, and nobody asked them.
Preparing a toddler beforehand
Plainly, and later than you think. Under about three, a child has very little sense of months, so telling them early means a long, confusing wait, and a few weeks' notice is enough for a two-year-old, while a three or four-year-old can cope with longer and will ask better questions.
Describe what will happen, not how they'll feel. "The baby will cry a lot and feed a lot and can't play" is far better preparation than "you'll love being a big brother", which is a promise nobody can keep, and which I made, twice.
Make any other big changes early, like moving to a bed, starting nursery, giving up a dummy or changing rooms, at least two months ahead, so the child doesn't connect them with the baby, which small children do very quickly.
Show them a real baby if you possibly can, or photos of themselves as a newborn, because otherwise they picture a baby as a toy that sits up and plays, and read a couple of books about new siblings, including one that admits the hard parts, since the ones where everybody is delighted all the way through don't prepare anyone for anything.
Tell them who will look after them while you're giving birth, and practise it if you can, because in my experience this is what worries a toddler most and what adults most often forget to mention, being busy worrying about the birth.
And don't promise a playmate. It's the most common thing parents say, and it sets up a disappointment that arrives in week two and stays.
What happens in the first weeks
Usually a calm spell, and then a reaction. Lots of toddlers are curious and cheerful for the first few days and then fall apart in week two or three, when they realise the baby is staying. Parents tend to think the early calm means the child has adjusted and the later upset is a step backwards, but it's one process, just running on its own timetable. Expect them to go backwards for a while, which is very common: toilet accidents in a trained child, wanting a bottle, baby talk, night waking, refusing to walk. Expect clinginess to one parent, often the one who's less available, and rejection of the other, which stings. Expect more aggression, usually aimed at a parent and not the baby, and usually right when your attention moves to the baby. Expect sleep to be disrupted, which lasts longest of all and is the least convenient, and once in a while expect the opposite, a very helpful, grown-up little person who's holding it all together and will let go later, and that's the child I watch most carefully, because I was that child. Going backwards isn't something to correct. It's the child asking to be looked after in the way they know means being cared for, and giving them that, feeding them, carrying them, letting the toilet training slide for two weeks, settles it much faster than standing firm does, whatever your mother-in-law says about spoiling.
The rest of the adjustment
When they hit the baby
It's common, it frightens parents, and it doesn't mean the child dislikes the baby. A toddler with strong feelings and not enough words uses their body, because that's what they have.
It still needs a quick, clear response, and the response is about keeping the baby safe, not about punishment.
Step in physically, straight away: block, move, separate, calmly and without a lecture. Say the rule in a few words, "I won't let you hit", in exactly the same way every time, and then name the feeling behind it, because "you wanted me" stops it happening again far better than punishing does, and I've tried both.
Never leave a toddler unsupervised with a newborn, however gentle they've been. That's a standing rule in every house I've ever run and it isn't a judgement on your child.
Give them something to do with the feeling, like squeezing a cushion, stamping, or coming to find you, and look for the pattern behind the hitting, because most of it happens around feeds and right when a parent's attention moves, and once you can see the pattern you can get there first.
Giving a toddler enough attention
Make a small amount of it reliable and undivided, and don't worry about making it a lot. Ten predictable minutes with no phone and no baby does more than an hour of half-attention, because what they've lost is having you to themselves, not time, and a two-year-old knows the difference perfectly well.
Protect one short daily slot that belongs to them, at the same point in the day, and give it a name so they can look forward to it. Where you can, let the other parent look after the baby while you take the toddler, because it's usually the other way round and the toddler notices immediately. Or so I'm told by my daughters, who have all made the mistake, as I did.
Give them real jobs with the baby, like fetching a nappy or choosing the muslin, since they'll see through pretend jobs within days, and don't blame the baby when you're busy, because "the baby needs me" tells a child exactly who's in the way, while "I'll be there in two minutes" doesn't.
Mentioned above
Take visitors' gifts seriously. Guests who bring presents for the newborn and nothing for the toddler hurt them, and it's easy to fix, and as a grandmother I'd say that's our job to get right, not the parents', so I keep a drawer of small things for exactly this.
Accept help with the newborn, not the toddler, so the time it frees up goes to the child who's struggling.
How long adjustment takes
Usually weeks to a few months for the worst of the behaviour, with sleep the last thing to settle, and it doesn't improve in a straight line: a good two weeks followed by a bad week is normal, and around six to eight weeks, when a partner often goes back to work and the visitors stop coming, there's often a second dip that nobody warns you about.
Take it to a doctor or health visitor if the behaviour is escalating and not easing after a couple of months, if the child becomes withdrawn or stops eating, or if the aggression can't be managed with ordinary supervision.
Mention your own mood there as well. The months after a second child arrives are a high-risk time for postnatal depression and anxiety, and in my experience the toddler's struggles get discussed at every appointment while the parent's go unmentioned, and I'd rather you mentioned yours.
Where this comes from
- American Academy of Pediatrics: Preparing your older child for a new baby
- Pregnancy, Birth and Baby: Toddler and the new baby
- NHS: Postnatal depression
This guide is general information, written to help you understand a topic and ask better questions. It is not medical advice and does not replace your own doctor, midwife or paediatrician. Anything that worries you about your baby belongs with them.
If this helped
← More on parenthoodAll 189 guidesShop: Everything from Little Rei →
