Trending Potty Training Tools

Potty training has become a big product category, which is strange for something that needs, at minimum, a child and somewhere to sit.
Richard finished this year, at three. We bought most of the things on the second list below before we worked out that almost none of them were helping. Most of what's sold is aimed at the parent's worries: the anxiety, the mess, the wish to be done. The child needs something else.
What signals readiness
No product replaces readiness, and starting before your child is ready is the most common reason potty training drags on and makes everyone miserable. Readiness comes with development. It usually shows up between about eighteen months and three years, with a wide normal range, and boys tend to be later on average. Look for staying dry for an hour or two at a time, which shows her bladder can hold more. Look for signs she notices: telling you during or after, hiding to poo, pulling at a wet diaper. Noticing always comes before control. Look for being able to walk to the potty and pull clothing up and down with some help, for following a simple two-step instruction, and for some interest in the toilet or in other people using it. And look at what else is going on, because a new sibling, a house move, starting childcare or an illness are all reasons to wait.
A child showing most of these signs will usually train in days or weeks. A child showing none of them will get there too, but it will take months. Waiting is the method, and for me it was the hardest part.
What to buy
Less than the shop suggests. Four things, and one of them isn't sold as potty equipment at all.
A low, stable floor potty, so her feet sit flat on the ground. Foot support matters more than parents expect. Children need to brace their feet to push, and that's why so many will wee on a toilet seat but won't poo on one.
A toilet seat reducer and a step for when you move up to the toilet. The step is the important part. Far more underwear than you think you need, and easy clothes with elastic waists, because buttons, dungarees and tights all slow her down and cause accidents.
A waterproof mattress protector, with a spare set of bedding made up underneath it if you're night training. A travel potty or folding seat if you're out a lot. It's the one good gadget in the whole category. A wipeable floor covering or a stack of old towels for the first few days at home. Our whole kit came to about S$70, and the potty was S$12 of that.
Before and after
What's being sold that doesn't help
Most of the rest, and some of it gets in the way.
Musical and light-up potties reward sitting, and some children learn to sit down again and again just to hear the tune. They also turn the potty into a toy, which is the wrong idea to teach. Potty training watches and reminder apps train the parent's timing. Children trained on a timer often take longer to recognise their own signals, because the device does the noticing for them. I don't know if anyone has studied this properly, but it's what I saw.
Charts and sticker systems do very little for most children under three. Rewards work for a short while and are hard to stop afterwards, and using the toilet shouldn't become a performance with a score.
Training pants that feel like diapers are just diapers. If a child can't tell she's wet, she isn't learning anything. The point of cloth training pants is that they feel unpleasant when wet. Most disposable ones don't.
A word on three-day potty training programmes. Some children do finish in three days, and they're the ones who were already ready. The method can't make a child ready, and selling it as a deadline leaves a lot of parents upset and convinced they've failed.
Tall splash guards, too. In my experience they're the main reason a child refuses to sit on a potty a second time.
Night training is a different thing
You can't train for it in the same way. Staying dry overnight depends on bladder size and on a hormone that makes the body produce less urine during sleep. Both develop on their own schedule, whatever you do.
Bedwetting is common well into the school years, and doctors don't treat it as a medical concern until around five, or later in some countries' guidance. So bedwetting alarms, lifting a sleeping child to the toilet and cutting back drinks are usually too early for a toddler.
Keep the diaper on at night until it's dry most mornings, and then stop. A mattress protector is all you need.
What makes it go well
Almost none of it is equipment, which is bad news for anyone selling equipment.
Start when she's ready. Preschools here sometimes push parents on this, but pressure doesn't make a child ready any sooner. Let her see people using the toilet, because copying you does more than any product.
Keep the potty wherever the child is for the first week, because a toddler won't interrupt play to walk to another room. Ours lived beside the sofa for two weeks. When accidents happen, don't react: no visible disappointment, no big clean-up show. An accident just tells you something.
Try not to ask if she needs a wee every twenty minutes, because then you're the one doing the noticing. Building it into the routine works better. Expect setbacks around illness, travel, a new sibling or starting childcare. They're normal and they pass.
See a doctor about pain or straining, constipation that doesn't clear, a child who holds in her poo, dribbling that never stops, blood, or a child who was reliably trained and has gone fully back to accidents for more than a few weeks. Constipation in particular is behind a lot of stalled potty training, and it's very treatable once someone spots it.
Sources: HealthHub: Ministry of Health Singapore · NHS: When to get medical help for your child
This guide is general information, written to help you understand a topic and ask better questions. It is not medical advice and does not replace your own doctor, midwife or paediatrician. Anything that worries you about your baby belongs with them.
Related
← More on essentials & gearAll 189 guidesShop: Little Rei luxury diapers →