Free delivery on orders over S$6030-day money backReiCare 365, our one-year warrantyDesigned in Singapore

Tackling the Transition to Whole Milk

A mother pouring milk from a jug into a glass for her young daughter at a kitchen counter, with cereal and fruit laid out

The switch to cow's milk is one of the few changes in the first two years with a set date. After eighteen months of everything being a spectrum, that's a relief.

When can a baby switch to cow's milk?

Twelve months as a main drink, not before. The reason is iron. Cow's milk is low in iron, and it blocks the body from absorbing iron from other food. In babies under one it can also irritate the gut lining enough to cause slow blood loss. Iron deficiency in the first year has consequences for development that aren't easily undone. This is a firm rule.

Cow's milk in food is different, and fine from six months: in a sauce, in porridge, in baking. Full-fat yoghurt and cheese are excellent early foods. It's milk as a drink that waits for the first birthday.

Whole milk, not semi-skimmed, until at least two. Toddlers need the fat for growth and brain development. This is where adult diet habits lead people wrong.

How much milk does a toddler need?

About 350 to 400ml a day, which is a lot less than most families give.

Above roughly 500ml, too much milk becomes the problem. A toddler full of milk has no appetite for food, and the milk blocks iron absorption from what little food she does eat. That's the most common cause of iron deficiency in the second year, and it's easy to avoid. We caught it in time with ours, I think. Not sure.

Give water between meals. Juice isn't needed at all. If she has some, dilute it well and give it with a meal, where it does less damage to teeth.

How to make the switch

Some children don't notice. Two of mine switched in an afternoon and couldn't have cared less.

For the others, mix it in over a week or two, changing the ratio and nothing else.

Blending cow's milk in over one to two weeks
DaysUsual milkCow's milk
1–33 parts1 part
4–71 part1 part
8–111 part3 parts
12+NoneAll
Any pointSlow down a step if she refusesChange one variable at a time

Serve it in a cup if you can. Doing both transitions at once is more efficient, and toddlers are more flexible than we credit. Warming it slightly helps in the first week for a child used to a warm bottle, and then drop it.

Around the same stage

What if they refuse it

That's common, and not a problem in itself. Milk as a drink isn't essential. What counts is calcium, vitamin D and fat, and she can get all three in other ways.

  • Full-fat yoghurt, cheese, and milk cooked into food all count and are frequently better received.
  • Porridge made with milk, or a milky sauce on pasta, gets a surprising amount in without her noticing.
  • Try it colder, or warmer, or in a different cup, since with toddlers the cup is often what they're objecting to.
  • Keep offering without pressure. It takes ten or more encounters, and making an issue of it guarantees a longer fight.
  • Don't extend formula or follow-on milk indefinitely to solve this. It's expensive and only puts the problem off.

If she takes very little dairy in any form, ask a health visitor or doctor about vitamin D and calcium. Don't work it out yourself.

What about toddler milks and plant milks

Toddler milks, growing-up milks and stage-three formulas aren't recommended by any health body I know of. A child eating a reasonable range of food doesn't need them. They're sweeter than cow's milk, they cost several times as much, and their main function is commercial. I say that as a commercial director, and I hope it has some weight.

Mentioned above

Silicone Multi Use CupSilicone Multi Use CupS$24.90
Mealtime SetMealtime SetS$88.00Sold out

Plant milks are a different question. Unsweetened fortified soya is the only one broadly considered a reasonable substitute in the second year, and it must be fortified with calcium and vitamin D. Almond, oat, coconut and rice milks are far too low in protein and energy to be a toddler's main drink. Rice milk specifically shouldn't be given under five, because of arsenic.

Avoiding dairy for allergy or family reasons? Do it with a dietitian, never alone. This is one of the few areas where getting it wrong can do real harm.

What about the bottle itself

Stop bottles between twelve and eighteen months, mainly for her teeth.

Introduce an open or straw cup from six months, so she's used to it by the time the bottles go. Daytime bottles go first, the bedtime one last. And never a bottle in the cot. Dentists would like that tattooed on every new parent. I've seen it ignored more than any other rule.

The ones people ask me

When can a baby start drinking cow's milk?

Most guidance puts cow's milk as a main drink at twelve months, with whole or full-fat milk through the second year. Cow's milk used in food, such as in cereal or sauces, is considered fine from around six months, and national guidance varies, so check yours.

How much milk should a toddler drink a day?

Commonly around 350 to 500 ml, roughly 12 to 16 fluid ounces, including milk in food, yoghurt and cheese. Above about 500 to 600 ml, milk starts displacing iron-rich foods and can contribute to iron-deficiency anaemia.

How do I switch my baby from formula to cow's milk?

Either straight over, or blended in steps across one to two weeks: three parts usual milk to one part cow's milk, then half and half, then one to three. Change one thing at a time: not bottle-to-cup and formula-to-milk in the same week.

What if my toddler won't drink milk?

It isn't essential. Calcium and fat are available from yoghurt, cheese, fortified plant milks, tinned fish with soft bones, calcium-set tofu and some greens and beans, and milk used in cooking still counts. Ask about vitamin D, which is often recommended as a supplement regardless.

Should I buy toddler milk?

Most health authorities consider them unnecessary for healthy children over one. They generally cost more than cow's milk and often contain added sugars, and regulators in several countries have criticised their health claims.

Can toddlers drink plant milk instead?

Most plant milks aren't suitable as a main drink under two, being lower in energy, fat and protein and variably fortified. Fortified soy is the closest substitute. Rice drinks are advised against for young children in several countries. If avoiding dairy, involve a dietitian.

Sources: American Academy of Pediatrics: Recommended drinks for ages 0: 5 · NHS: Drinks and cups for babies and young children

This guide is general information, written to help you understand a topic and ask better questions. It is not medical advice and does not replace your own doctor, midwife or paediatrician. Anything that worries you about your baby belongs with them.

Next

← More on feedingAll 189 guidesShop: Bibs and feeding →

Chat with us